To determine the appropriate extent to which ENI S.p.A. should utilize hybrid bonds, we must analyze its current capital structure, financial performance, cash flow generation, and the specific guidelines provided for hybrid issuance.

**1. Current Capital Structure and Hybrid Status**
First, we identify the existing level of hybrid debt. The facts state:
*   "Decrease Through Coupon Payment On Perpetual Subordinated Bonds Equity" for 2022 was 138,000,000 EUR.
*   "Proceeds From Issuing Other Equity Instruments" in 2021 was ~2 billion EUR, and in 2020 was ~3 billion EUR.
*   "Payments Of Other Equity Instruments" in 2022 was 138,000,000 EUR (likely coupon payments treated as equity distributions or minor redemptions, but the line item "Decrease Through Coupon Payment..." confirms these are perpetual subordinated bonds classified as equity).
*   Crucially, there is no line item for a large outstanding principal of perpetual bonds in the liabilities or equity breakdown that suggests a massive existing buffer, but the presence of coupon payments indicates existing hybrids. However, looking at the equity composition, "Other Reserves" and "Retained Earnings" are significant. The prompt asks to consider the *starting point*. While the exact outstanding principal of hybrids isn't explicitly summed in a single "Hybrid Debt" line, the coupon payment of 138m EUR suggests an outstanding nominal amount. Assuming a typical coupon of 4-5%, the outstanding hybrid debt is roughly 2.7 - 3.4 billion EUR.
*   Total Equity (2023-01-01): 55,230,000,000 EUR.
*   Total Liabilities (2023-01-01): 96,900,000,000 EUR.
*   Total Adjusted Capital (Equity + Adjusted Debt): For this analysis, we approximate Adjusted Debt as Total Liabilities (noting that some short-term debt might be netted against cash in specific sector adjustments, but ENI is an E&P/Integrated major, not a regulated utility with seasonal working capital adjustments of that nature). Let's use Total Capital = Equity + Total Liabilities = 55.23bn + 96.9bn = 152.13bn EUR.
*   Current Hybrid %: If outstanding hybrids are ~3bn, this represents approx 2% of Total Capital. This is well below the 15% cap.

**2. Financial Performance and Cash Flow**
*   **Profitability:** ENI reported a strong "Profit Loss From Operating Activities" of 17,510,000,000 EUR and "Profit Loss" of 13,961,000,000 EUR for 2022. This is a significant improvement from 2021 (5,840m EUR) and 2020 (-8,628m EUR).
*   **Cash Flow:** "Cash Flows From Used In Operating Activities" was 17,460,000,000 EUR. This is a very strong operating cash flow generation.
*   **Investing Activities:** "Cash Flows From Used In Investing Activities" was -7,018,000,000 EUR.
*   **Financing Activities:** "Cash Flows From Used In Financing Activities" was -8,542,000,000 EUR, driven by dividends (3,009m EUR), share buybacks (2,400m EUR), and debt repayments.
*   **Free Cash Flow:** Operating CF (17.46bn) - Investing CF (7.02bn) = ~10.44bn EUR. This is a robust positive free cash flow.

**3. Leverage and Refinancing Needs**
*   **Debt Levels:** Short-term borrowings (4.45bn) + Current portion of long-term (3.10bn) + Long-term borrowings (19.37bn) = ~26.92bn EUR in interest-bearing debt.
*   **Net Debt:** Total Debt (~27bn) - Cash (10.15bn) = ~16.85bn EUR.
*   **Leverage Ratio:** Net Debt / EBITDA. EBITDA can be approximated from Operating Profit (17.51bn) + Depreciation (7.2bn) = ~24.7bn EUR. Net Debt/EBITDA is approx 0.68x. This is a very low leverage ratio for an Oil & Gas major.
*   **Refinancing:** The company has low refinancing pressure relative to its cash generation. It is actively reducing debt (Repayments of noncurrent borrowings 4.07bn vs Proceeds 0.13bn) and returning cash to shareholders.

**4. Assessment Against Guidelines**
*   **0% Argument:** The company has a strong rating profile (implied by low leverage and high cash flow), low refinancing needs, and strong credit metrics. Issuing hybrids would increase the cost of capital because hybrid coupons are higher than senior debt yields (as seen in the swap curves and bond spreads, hybrids carry a subordination premium). The guideline for 0% states: "Low refinancing needs... Hybrid issuance would not improve rating or leverage metrics... Strong rating profile... Cost of hybrid will materially increase the current cost of debt."
*   **3.75% Argument:** This option is for "Moderate funding needs" or "Mild leverage optimization." ENI does not have moderate funding needs; it has excess cash. It is buying back shares and paying dividends. It does not need to optimize leverage downwards as it is already very low.
*   **Higher Percentages (7.5% - 15%):** These are reserved for companies with high capex, acquisition pipelines, or leverage pressure. ENI's capex (Purchase of PPE 7.7bn) is well covered by operating cash flow. There is no evidence of a transformational M&A program requiring hybrid financing. There is no downgrade risk; rather, the balance sheet is strengthening.

**5. Market Conditions**
*   Interest rates rose significantly in 2022 (5Y Swap avg 1.726% vs -0.264% in 2021). The cost of issuing new hybrids would be higher than in previous years. Given the company's strong cash position and low leverage, locking in higher-cost hybrid capital is not financially prudent when the company can fund operations and growth through internal cash flows or cheaper senior debt if necessary.

**Conclusion**
ENI S.p.A. exhibits a very strong financial position with low leverage, high cash flow generation, and no pressing refinancing or funding needs that would necessitate the higher cost of hybrid capital. The issuance of hybrids would not meaningfully improve its already strong credit metrics or rating profile. Therefore, the company should not issue additional hybrid bonds at this time.

<answer>0%</answer>