## Reasoning ### Step 1: Calculate Net Debt (S&P methodology) S&P's Net Debt typically includes: - Short-term borrowings + Long-term borrowings + Non-current financial liabilities - Cash and cash equivalents From the balance sheet at 2023-01-01 (end of 2022): - Long-term Borrowings: 28,083M EUR - Current Borrowings and Current Portion of Noncurrent Borrowings: 12,508M EUR - Other Noncurrent Financial Liabilities: 90M EUR - Cash and Cash Equivalents: 15,570M EUR S&P also typically adds: - 50% of deeply subordinated perpetual notes (hybrid instruments) as debt. The Deeply Subordinated Perpetual Notes at end of 2022 = 3,393M EUR. S&P typically gives 50% equity / 50% debt credit, so add 50% = 1,697M EUR as debt. However, let me note that S&P's treatment can vary. For a standard estimate: **Gross Debt** = Long-term Borrowings + Current Borrowings + 50% of hybrids = 28,083 + 12,508 + 1,697 = 42,288M EUR Actually, let me reconsider. S&P's net debt calculation typically: - Total debt = short-term + long-term borrowings - Plus adjustments for operating leases (already in PP&E under IFRS 16), pensions, hybrids, etc. For simplicity with available data: - Total borrowings: 28,083 + 12,508 = 40,591M EUR - Plus 50% hybrids: 1,697M EUR - Less cash: 15,570M EUR **Net Debt** = 40,591 + 1,697 - 15,570 = **26,718M EUR** ### Step 2: Calculate EBITDA (S&P methodology) S&P EBITDA = Operating income + Depreciation & Amortization From the income statement for 2022 (period 2022-01-01 to 2023-01-01): Current Operating Income Including Operating MtM: 4,309M EUR Add back: Depreciation, Amortization and Provisions: 5,187M EUR EBITDA (from current operations) = 4,309 + 5,187 = 9,496M EUR However, S&P typically uses EBITDA that includes the share of equity method entities but adjusts for non-recurring items. Let me think more carefully. S&P's EBITDA typically starts from revenues and subtracts operating costs (excluding D&A): - Revenue: 93,865M - Purchases and Operating Derivatives: -74,535M - Employee Benefits: -8,078M - Tax Expense Other Than Income Tax: -3,380M - Other Income: +1,624M = Current Operating Income before D&A = 93,865 - 74,535 - 8,078 - 3,380 + 1,624 = 9,496M So EBITDA from continuing operations = 9,496M EUR S&P may also add dividends received from equity method investments rather than the share of net income. The data shows: - "Adjustments For Dividend Income" (in cash flow): -713M EUR (this appears to be dividends received from equity method investments that are added back) For S&P, they often include cash dividends from equity-accounted entities. The dividend income adjustment of 713M suggests dividends received. S&P EBITDA ≈ 9,496 + 713 = 10,209M EUR Actually, let me reconsider. S&P's approach typically: - EBITDA = Revenue - operating costs (excl D&A) + dividends from equity affiliates - Or sometimes they just use reported EBITDA and add equity affiliate dividends Let me use a more straightforward approach: - EBITDA = Current Operating Income Including Operating MtM + D&A + Share of equity method income - = 4,309 + 5,187 + 1,059 = 10,555M EUR Or using dividends instead of equity income: - = 4,309 + 5,187 + 713 = 10,209M EUR ### Step 3: Calculate Ratio Using EBITDA = 9,496M (just operating EBITDA without equity method): Net Debt / EBITDA = 26,718 / 9,496 = 2.81x Using EBITDA = 10,209M (with dividends from affiliates): Net Debt / EBITDA = 26,718 / 10,209 = 2.62x Using EBITDA = 10,555M (with share of equity income): Net Debt / EBITDA = 26,718 / 10,555 = 2.53x S&P typically uses EBITDA including dividends from equity affiliates = 10,209M. Net Debt / EBITDA = 26,718 / 10,209 ≈ 2.6x Let me reconsider whether S&P would include the full hybrid as debt or 50%. Given standard S&P treatment of ENGIE's hybrids (intermediate equity content = 50% debt): Net Debt / EBITDA ≈ 26,718 / 10,209 ≈ 2.6 2.6